Possibilities of comparing the average annual effective doses of medical personnel in Russia and some foreign countries

The analysis of published data on the average annual effective doses to personnel of Russia, Germany, Switzerland, France and Canada in dynamics for 2013-2017 was performed. It was established that in the countries under consideration there are significant differences in the processing of primary measurement information, the calculation on its basis of individual effective doses, as well as ways of averaging the data obtained and their presentation. Factors that may lead to different interpretations of the results are considered: – taking into account background doses due to natural radiation; – use in processing the results of various (in different countries) values of the minimum level of registration; – dose averaging in the absence of activity periods (loss of a dosimeter / vacation), and when registering unexpectedly high doses. These differences exist between the data of foreign countries, but the data presented by the Russian Joint state system of control and accounting of the individual doses of the citizens are especially different. It is shown that the data on average annual effective doses to personnel presented in the Federal Data Base of personnel exposure doses within the framework of the Russian Joint state system of control and accounting of the individual doses is 3-4 times higher than in foreign countries. It is shown that such a difference is caused not by actually high doses, but by the method of processing primary information and averaging data during generalization. It should be noted that such differences occur only for extremely small doses of technogenic exposure to personnel, and do not lead to a significant impact on the overall assessment of the state of radiation safety in the country, but when comparing with other countries, it is necessary to understand the reasons for such differences. The purpose of this work was to identify the causes of these discrepancies and to develop a method for processing primary measurement information and averaging the data when summarizing the results, which allows them to be significantly reduced. Such a method should ensure that the effective doses of personnel closest to the conditionally true values are obtained in the entire range of values, and can be used to summarize the data contained in the Federal Data Base of personnel exposure doses. Since the conversion of the data contained in the Federal Data Base of personnel exposure doses was not the task of the authors of this article, in order to achieve this goal, an attempt was made to process and summarize the measurement results (total 23 204) of the quarterly values of the individual dose equivalent Hp (10) obtained in the Laboratory of Radiation Control of Saint-Petersburg Research Institute of the Radiation Hygiene after Professor P.V. Ramzaev. Such processing has been performed. The subsequent comparison showed that the average annual effective doses to the personnel of medical organizations of St.-Petersburg, in which individual dosimetric control was carried out in the Laboratory of Radiation Control, transformed according to the developed algorithm, are much better consistent with similar data from foreign countries.

1. Medvedev AYu. Comparative assessment of radiation doses to personnel in Russia and abroad. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2010;3(2): 45-51 (In Russian).

2. Repin VS, Baryshkov NK, Bratilova AA, Kormanovskaya TA, Kuvshinnikov SI, Matyukhin SV, et al. Doses to the population of the Russian Federation in 2013: information collection. Saint-Petersburg; 2014. 60 p. (In Russian).

3. Repin VS, Baryshkov NK, Bratilova AA, Varfolomeeva KV, Goncharova YuN, Kononenko DV, et al. The results of the operation of the Unified State System for Monitoring and Accounting for Individual Exposure Doses of Citizens of the Russian Federation according to 2014 data. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2015;8(3): 86-115 (In Russian).

4. Barkovsky AN, Baryshkov NK, Bratilova AA, Kormanovskaya TA, Repin LV, Romanovich IK, et al. Doses for the population of the Russian Federation in 2015: information collection. Saint-Petersburg: NIIRG; 2016: 73 (In Russian).

5. Onischenko GG, Popova AYu, Romanovich IK, Barkovsky AN, Kormanovskaya TA, Shevkun IG. Radiation-hygienic certification and ESKID – information basis for managerial decisions to ensure radiation safety of the population of the Russian Federation. Communication 1. Main achievements and tasks for improvement. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation hygiene. 2017;10(3): 7-17. https://doi.org/10.21514/1998-426X-2017-10-3-7-17 (In Russian).

6. Barkovsky AN, Akhmatdinov RR, Akhmatdinov RR, Baryshkov NK, Biblin AM, Bratilova AA, et al. Results of the operation of the Unified State System for Monitoring and Accounting for Individual Doses of Irradiation of Citizens of the Russian Federation according to 2017 data. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation hygiene. 2018;11(4): 98-128 (In Russian).

7. The official website of the European Platform for Occupational Radiation Exposure. Available from: https://esorex-platform.org [Accessed 04.03.2020] (In Russian).

8. 2018 Report on occupational radiation exposures in Canada, published by authority of the Minister of Health, Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, as represented by the Minister of Health, 2018 – Pub.: 170264, Cat.: H126-1E-PDF.

9. Sources and Effects of Ionizing Radiation: United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation; 2000. Report. Volume I, Annex E.

10. Romanovich IK, Stamat IP, Kormanovskaya TA, Kononenko DV, Balabina TA, Bashketova NS, et al. Natural sources of ionizing radiation: radiation doses, radiation risks, preventive measures. Ed. by Acad. of the RAS Onischenko GG and Prof. Popova AYu. Saint-Petersburg: NIIRG after Professor P.V. Ramzaev; 2018. 432 p. (In Russian).

11. ICRP Publication 74. Conversion Coefficients for Use in Radiological Protection against External Radiation. International Commission on Radiological Protection, 1997.

12. ICRP. Conversion Coefficients for Radiological Protection Quantities for External Radiation Exposures. ICRP Publication 116, Annals of the ICRP. 2010. 40(2-5).

13. Occupational radiation protection. International Atomic Energy Agency. Vienna: International Atomic Energy Agency, 2018. Series: IAEA safety standards series, ISSN 1020-525X; no. GSG-7. Includes bibliographical references.