Validation of a method for in situ determination of 137Cs soil contamination density in kitchen gardens using the portable spectrometer-dosimeter MKS AT6101D

The collection of representative soil samples in the territory of settlements and subsequent measurements of the content of radionuclides in these samples under laboratory conditions (the so-called “ex situ method”) is a generally accepted technology for determining the density of soil contamination with ¹³⁷Cs in the populated areas contaminated due to the Chernobyl accident. Recently, as a supplement or alternative to the ex situ method, researchers are developing field (in situ) gamma-spectrometry methods. These methods allow determining the density of soil contamination with 137Cs directly on site, without soil sampling and laboratory analysis. At the same time, the in situ methodology has several limitations, the most important of which is a lack of generally recognized metrological basis for measurements and interpretation of results. Hence, before using a particular technique and measuring device for carrying out large-scale in situ measurements, it is necessary to validate (to assess the suitability) of the selected in situ method using an established ex situ method. The aim of this study was to validate the method for determining the density of ¹³⁷Cs soil contamination in kitchen gardens using the MKS AT6101D spectrometer-dosimeter in situ. The method was recently presented by a Russian-Swedish-Belarusian group of researchers in an article published in the Journal of Environmental Radioactivity (https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvrad.2021.106562). To validate this method, we selected 10 representative kitchen garden plots. The plots were located in six settlements of the Bryansk region in Russia. The territory of the settlements had been heavily contaminated with ¹³⁷Cs as a result of the Chernobyl accident: the officially established levels of the density of soil contamination by ¹³⁷Cs ranged from 111 to 511 kBq/m² in 2017. Field gamma-ray spectra were recorded at a height of 1 m above the ground in the center of kitchen garden plots using the MKS AT6101D device. The measurement duration was in the range of 1207–1801 s (the mean value = 1383 s). Samples of soil in the kitchen gardens were taken layer by layer (with a step of 5 cm) to a depth of 20 cm using a demountable cylindrical sampler. The 137Cs content in each soil layer was determined in the laboratory using a stationary semiconductor gamma spectrometer. The values of the 137Cs contamination density of the sampled soils ranged from 77 to 548 kBq/m². It was found that the results of the ex situ analyzes of soil samples were in a good agreement with the contamination density values obtained with the in situ method. On average, the difference between two methodologies was 7% (a maximum of 20%). The results of the study confirm that the method proposed by the international group is suitable for determining the density of soil contamination by 137Cs in kitchen gardens in remote period after the Chernobyl accident.

1. Bruk GYa, Bazyukin AB, Bratilova AA, Vlasov AYu, Goncharova YuN, Gromov AV, et al. The average annual effective doses for the population in the settlements of the Russian Federation attributed to zones of radioactive contamination due to the Chernobyl accident (for zonation purposes), 2014. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2015;8(2): 32–128. (In Russian).

2. Bruk GYa, Romanovich IK, Bazyukin AB, Bratilova AA, Vlasov AYu, Gromov AV, et al. The average annual effective doses for the population in the settlements of the Russian Federation attributed to zones of radioactive contamination due to the Chernobyl accident (for zonation purposes), 2017. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2017;10(4): 73–78. (In Russian).

3. Romanovich IK, Bruk GYa, Barkovsky AN, Bratilova AA, Gromov AV, Kaduka MV. Substantiation of the concept of transfer to conditions of normal population activity of the settlements considered to be zones of radioactive contamination after the Chernobyl NPP accident. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2016;9(1): 6–18. (In Russian).

4. Orlov MYu, Snykov VP, Bochkov LP. Determination of average ground 137Cs contamination. Atomnaya Energia = Atomic Energy. 1994;76(3): 212–217. (In Russian).

5. Hille R, Hill P, Heinemann K, Ramzaev V, Barkovski A, Konoplia V, et al. Current development of the human and environmental contamination in the Bryansk–Gomel spot due to the Chernobyl accident. Radiation and Environmental Biophysics. 2000;39: 99–109.

6. Nilova EK, Bortnovsky VN, Tagai SA, Dudareva NV, Nikitin AN. Assessment of the current levels of 241Am and 137Сs in soils and foodstuff, as well as of public internal exposure to ionizing radiation in populated areas adjacent to the Chernobyl NPP exclusion zone (case study: the Bragin district of the Gomel region, Belarus). Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2020;13(3): 25–37. (In Russian).

7. Ramzaev V, Yonehara H, Hille R, Barkovsky A, Mishine A, Sahoo SK, et al. Gamma-dose rates from terrestrial and Chernobyl radionuclides inside and outside settlements in the Bryansk Region, Russia in 1996–2003. Journal of Environmental Radioactivity. 2006;85: 205–227.

8. Rostron P, Heathcote JA, Ramsey MH. Comparison between measurement methods for the characterisation of radioactively contaminated land. Workshop on Radiological Characterisation for Decommissioning, Nyköping, Sweden 17–19 April 2012.

9. Rostron PD, Heathcote JA, Ramsey MH. Comparison between in situ and ex situ gamma measurements on land areas within a decommissioning nuclear site: a case study at Dounreay. Journal of Radiological Protection. 2014;34 (3): 495–508.

10. ICRU – International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements. Gamma-Ray Spectrometry in the Environment. ICRU report: No. 53. 1994. Bethesda, Maryland, USA.

11. Tyler AN, Sanderson DCW, Scott EM. Estimating and accounting for 137Cs source burial through In situ gamma spectrometry in salt marsh environments. Journal of Environmental Radioactivity.1996;33: 195–212.

12. Chesnokov AV, Govorun AP, Fedin VN, Ivanov OP, Liksonov VI, Potapov VN, et al. Method and device to measure 137Cs soil contamination in-situ. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment. 1999;420: 336–344.

13. Drovnikov VV, Egorov MV, Egorov NY, Zhivun VM, Kadushkin AV, Kovalenko VV, et al. In situ gamma spectroscopy with basically new abilities. Some results of In situ determination of artificial and natural radionuclides concentrations in soils. ANRI. 2011;64(1): 56–64. (In Russian).

14. Mikami S, Sato S, Hoshide Y, Sakamoto R, Okuda N, Saito K. In situ gamma spectrometry intercomparison in Fukushima, Japan. Japanese Journal of Health Physics. 2015;50(3): 182–188.

15. Varley A, Tyler A, Dowdall M, Bondar Y, Zabrotski V. An in situ method for the high resolution mapping of 137Cs and estimation of vertical depth penetration in a highly contaminated environment. Science of the Total Environment. 2017;605–606: 957–966.

16. Ramzaev V, Bernhardsson C, Dvornik A, Barkovsky A, Vodovatov A, Jönsson M. In situ determination of 137Cs inventory in soil using a field-portable scintillation gamma spectrometer-dosimeter. Journal of Environmental Radioactivity. 2021;231: 106562. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvrad.2021.106562.

17. ATOMTEX, 2020. AT6101D spectrometer (in Russian). Available on: https://atomtex.com/sites/default/files/datasheets/mks-at6101d.pdf. (Accessed 12 September 2020).

18. Ramzaev V, Barkovsky A, Bernhardsson C, Mattsson S. Calibration and testing of a portable NaI(Tl) gamma-ray spectrometer-dosimeter for evaluation of terrestrial radionuclides and 137Cs contributions to ambient dose equivalent rate outdoors. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2017;10(1): 18–29.

19. Ramzaev V, Bernhardsson C, Barkovsky A, Romanovich I, Jarneborn J, Mattsson S, et al. A backpack γ-spectrometer for measurements of ambient dose equivalent rate, H*(10), from 137Cs and from naturally occurring radiation: the importance of operator related attenuation. Radiation Measurements. 2017;107: 14–22.

20. Ramzaev V, Bernhardsson C, Dvornik A, Barkovsky A, Vodovatov A, Jönsson M, et al. Calculation of the effective external dose rate to a person staying in the resettlement zone of the Vetka district of the Gomel region of Belarus based on in situ and ex situ assessments in 2016–2018. Journal of Environmental Radioactivity. 2020;214–215: 106168.

21. Ramzaev VP, Barkovsky AN. Correlation between calculated and measured values of gamma dose rate in air in forests contaminated with 137Cs: the remote period after the Chernobyl accident. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2019;12(4); 37–46. (In Russian).

22. Bernhardsson C, Stenström KE, Mattsson S, Jönsson M, Pedehontaa-Hiaa G, Rääf C, et al. Zero point assessment of the radiation environment – examples of a program applied in Sweden (ESS) and in Belarus (Belnpp). Proceedings of International Conference “Medical Physics 2019” 7 – 9 November 2019, Kaunas University of Technology, Kaunas, Lithuania. 2019, P. 85–88.

23. Ramzaev VP, Barkovsky AN. Method for identifying areas of virgin soils using a portable gamma spectrometer-dosimeter. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation Hygiene. 2020;13(2): 123–128. (In Russian).