Results of the clinical evaluation of the low-dose protocols of the digital linear tomography of the chest

High levels of tuberculosis morbidity in the Russian Federation lead to the extensive use of X-ray diagnostics for the tuberculosis screening and assessment of the effectiveness of treatment. Digital radiography and computed tomography are traditionally used for the diagnostics of tuberculosis. These methods are associated with significant drawbacks: low specificity for radiography, high costs per examination, significant patient doses, and limited availability for computed tomography. As an additional method for the assessment of the effectiveness of the tuberculosis treatment it is possible to use linear tomography performed on the digital X-ray units. The aim of the current study was to evaluate the possibility of utilization of the digital linear tomography for the control of the effectiveness of tuberculosis treatment in a dedicated antitubercular medical facility. The study was divided in two stages. The first stage was aimed at the assessment of the diagnostic image quality of the digital linear tomograms obtained using the previously developed low-dose imaging protocols. Image quality assessment was performed using an anthropomorphic chest phantom and dedicated imitators of the lung lesions. Image quality was assessed by the experts (radiologists) based on the developed image quality criteria. Results of the first stage of the study indicate that all low-dose protocols allow obtaining images with at least acceptable image quality. Hence it was possible to propose low-dose protocols for clinical evaluations. The second stage of the study was performed as a prospective cohort survey aimed at the evaluation of the structure of X-ray examinations, patient doses and clinical image quality of the digital linear tomograms in antitubercular early treatment center. The cohort survey included two patient samples, uniform by age and gender composition, anthropometric characteristics and structure of diagnosis. One of the samples was imaged using standard (vendor) digital linear protocols, other – using the proposed low-dose protocols. Dose data collection (measurement of dose-area product and subsequent calculation of effective dose) and expert image quality assessment was performed for each patient. The results of the second stage of the study indicate that the use of the low-dose protocols allow reducing the patient effective doses per examination up to a factor of 6–8 (0.56 – 5.9 mSv for standard protocols; 0.2 – 1.15 mSv for low-dose protocols) due to the reduction in tube current-time product (126 mean mAs and 11 mean mAs, respectively). The dose reduction is accompanied by the reduction in the image quality of the linear tomograms (from “excellent” or “good” for standard protocols to “acceptable” for low-dose protocols). However, that dose not hinder the conclusion decision and identification of pathologies. Results of the study indicate that digital linear tomography can be used for the evaluation of the dynamics of the pathological process in the lungs with the previously defined localization of the pathology. The presented low-dose protocols were implemented into radiological practice of the antitubercular early treatment center. Currently, the proposed low-dose protocols are under evaluation for the large-scale study on the base of general practice hospitals

digital linear tomography, tuberculosis, effective dose, optimization, diagnostic image quality assessment

1. Vasilieva IA, Belilovsky EM. Tuberculosis combined with HIV infection in the countries of the world and in the Russian Federation. Tuberkulez i bolezni legkikh=Tuberculosis and lung diseases. 2017;95(9): 8-12. (In Russian)

2. The analytical review of the statistical indicators for tuberculosis used in the Russian Federation in 2011: Tuberculosis in the Russian Federation. Moscow; 2010. 223 p. (In Russian)

3. World Health Organization. 2016 Global Tuberculosis Control Report / World Health Organization. Available from: www. who.int/tb/publications/global_report/gtbr2016_executive_ summary_en.pdf [Accessed 3 February 2020] (In Russian)

4. World Health Organization. Systematic screening for active tuberculosis. Principles and recommendations. WHO/HTM/ TB/2013.04. Geneva, World Health Organization. 2013: 137.

5. World Health Organization. Tuberculosis Fact Sheet No. 104. 2017 / World Health Organization: Available from: www.who. int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs104/en. [Accessed 2 March 2020]

6. Health care in Russian Federation. 2015: Stat. Sat. Moscow: Rosstat; 2015. 174 p. (In Russian)

7. Vodovatov AV, Drozdov AA, Telnova AYu, Bernhardsson C. Management of patient doses from digital X-ray chest screening examinations. Rad. Prot. Dosim. 2016;169(1-4): 232-239.

8. Balonov M, Golikov V, Zvonova I, Chipiga L, Kalnitsky S, Sarycheva S, et al. Patient doses from medical examinations in Russia: 2009–2015. J. Radiol. Prot.; 38: 121-140. DOI: https: //doi.org/10.1088/1361-6498/aa9b99

9. Balonov MI, Golikov VYu, Zvonova IA, Kalnitsky SA, Repin VS, Sarycheva SS, et al. Current levels of medical exposure in Russia. Radiatsionnaya Gygiena = Radiation hygiene. 2015;8(3): 67-79. (In Russian)

10. Tyurin IE. Single nodules in lungs: the possibility of radiation diagnostics. Prakticheskaya pulmonologiya= Practical pulmonology. 2008;(2): 15-22. (In Russian)

11. Tyurin IE. Screening of respiratory diseases: current trends. Prakticheskaya pulmonologiya= Practical pulmonology. 2011; (2): 12-16. (In Russian)

12. Aviram G. Chest radiography for tuberculosis screening: a valuable tool. Isr. Med. Assoc. J. 2015;17(1): 50-51.

13. Li Q, Fan L, Cao ET, Li QC, Gu YF, & Liu SY. Quantitative CT analysis of pulmonary pure ground-glass nodule predicts histological invasiveness. European Journal of Radiology. 2017;89: 67–71.

14. Lee SW, Jang YS, Park CM, et al. The role of chest CT scanning in TB outbreak investigation. Chest. 2010;137(5): 1057-1064.

15. Nakanishi M, Demura Y, Ameshima S, et al. Utility of highresolution tomography for predicting risk of spu-tum smearnegative pulmonary tuberculosis. Eur. J. Radiol. 2010;73: 545-550.

16. Chipiga LA, Bernhardsson C. Patient doses in Computed Tomography examinations in two regions of the Russian Federation. Rad. Prot. Dos. 2016; 169(1-4): 240-244. 17. Pomozgov AI, Ternova SK. Tomography of chest. Kiev: Health; 1992: 188. (In Russian)

17. Uvarov VV. Classical (analogue) tomography – history, current status. Russian Association of Radiologists. Moscow; 2016: 136-142. (In Russian)

18. Vodovatov AV, Kamyshanskaya IG, Boriskina AN. Evaluation of effective doses in digital linear tomography for chest. Proceedings of Nevsky Radiological Forum 2019. Radiation diagnostics and therapy. 2019;1(9): 160-161. (In Russian)

19. Vodovatov AV, Kamyshanskaya IG, Boriskina AN. The technique of low-dose digital linear tomography for chest. Proceedings of Nevsky Radiological Forum 2019. Radiation diagnostics and therapy. 2019;1(9): 161-162. (In Russian)

20. Berkovich GV, Chipiga LA, Vodovatov AV, Silin AY, Karatetskiy AA, Trufanov GE. Optimization of low-dose chest CT protocols for the evaluation of the ground glass nodules using different iterative reconstruction algorithms. Luchevaya diagnostika i terapiya= Diagnostic radiology and radiotherapy. 2019;(4): 20-32. (In Russian) https://doi. org/10.22328/2079-5343-2019-10-4-20-32

21. Aichinger H. Radiation exposure and image quality in x-ray diagnostic radiology: physical principles and clinical applications. Heidelberg: New York: Springer, 2012. 2nd ed – XIV. 307 p.

22. Dance DR, Chrostofides S, Maidment ADA, McJean ID. Diagnostic radiology physics: A Handbook for teachers and students. Ng, Techn. Ed. – Vienna, IAEA: 2014.