Scientific articles
The third article in a series of publications devoted to the results of studying the current radiation situation in the territories of the Bryansk region bordering the Republic of Belarus presents results of studies of the content of radionuclides (137Cs and 90Sr) in samples of agricultural food products produced in the personal subsidiary plots of the population. The regularities of changing 137Cs and 90Sr content in samples of cow’s milk and potatoes depending on the level of radioactive contamination of the territory were studied; the present values of the quantities characterizing the distribution of the ratio of the activity concentration of radionuclides in agricultural food products to the density of radioactive contamination of the soil of the territory were deter -mined. The ratios of average values of 137Cs activity concentration in milk from stalled and grazing periods for cattle were analyzed. The results of the study show that some dairy product samples (less than 1%) do not meet the radiological safety criterion. Exceedances of the hygienic standards were not found in the studied samples of potatoes, vegetables, and meat of farm animals.
Evaluation of the low dose effect on population health is still a relevant issue. It requires further studies to improve our understanding of these effects. To solve this problem, it is important to conduct studies of the late effects of radiation exposure with direct risk estimation in the population that combines all strata of the society: people of different sex, age, initial health status, social and economic status. Moreover, this population should be sizeable and has been followed up for a long-term period. This manuscript is the first to present the findings of the analysis of the incidence risk of cancer of all the digestive organs, excluding intestines, and stomach cancer taken separately in members of the Southern Urals Population Exposed to Radiation Cohort depending on the dose accumulated in the stomach over the period from 1956 through 2018. This cohort is comprised of individuals exposed in the Southern Urals in two radiation accidents (on the Techa River and in the East-Urals Radioactive Trace) over the period from 01.01.1950 through 31.12.1960. The cohort also includes those who were born during this period; they could have additional in utero exposure or have exposed parents. The population was affected by long-term combined exposure (external and internal) at the low-to-medium soft tissue dose range (up to 1.1 Gy). The size of the incidence cohort was 47,282 people. Over the follow-up period 01.01.1956-31.12.2018, the number of person-years made up 1 292 930; mean dose to the stomach was 47 mGy, maximum – 1,132 mGy. Excess relative risk of the cancer incidence of the digestive organs was assessed using the Poisson regression analysis. Calculations were performed using the EPICURE Statistical software package. Excess relative risk for stomach cancer with a 2-year minimal, was 0.98/Gy (р=0.026), for all cancers of the digestive organs, excluding intestines, – 0.58/Gy, р=0.06. There was no significant modification of the effect by non-radiation factors. These values of excess relative risk do not disagree with the results of similar studies in the Japanese cohort of the atomic bomb survivors who were compatible in terms of age but had acute exposure at higher doses. No significant dose dependence of the cancer incidence of the oral cavity, esophagus, liver, or pancreas was detected at this stage.
Colorectal cancer (colon, rectum, rectosigmoid and anus) is one of the most frequently registered cancer sites. Apart from main risk factors for the development of cancer of this localization (dietary disorders, obesity, alcohol and tobacco use, contact with certain chemicals), a number of authors have noted in their studies the effect of ionizing radiation. The objective of this study was to directly assess the excess relative risk of colorectal cancer in the population exposed to long-term chronic radiation mainly in the range of low-dose and low dose rates. These people are included in the Southern Urals Population Exposed to Radiation Cohort. Materials and methods: the analytical cohort included 47,282 people, the follow-up period was 63 years (from 1956 to 2018), and the number of person years at risk was 1,292,930. The incidence catchment area includes five Chelyabinsk Oblast raions, the cities of Chelyabinsk and Ozersk. For the period from 1956 to 2018, 462 cases of colon cancer were registered in the follow-up territory. The colon dose was used as a reference dose. The mean absorbed dose was 69 mGy, the maximum dose – 1,824 mGy. The analysis was performed using Epicure statistical package programs by Poisson regression method with a simple parametric model of excess relative risk. Significance of the results was assessed by the maximum likelihood method with 95% probability. Results: In SUPER members, baseline colorectal cancer incidence rates were found to be dependent on such factors as sex (p<0.001), ethnicity (p=0.001), attained age (p<0.001), education (p<0.001), year of birth of cohort members (p<0.001), presence of cancer in first degree relatives (p=0.03). The risk analysis did not reveal statistically significant dose dependence of the excess relative risk of malignant neoplasms of the whole large intestine, as well as no significant dependence of the excess risk of malignant neoplasms of the colon and rectum. The influence of modifying factors on the magnitude of radiogenic risk was evaluated. Assessment of the excess relative risk of colorectal cancer in this cohort is carried out for the first time.
In the Russian Federation, there is a constant increase in the number of radiation medical installations with electron accelerators. Over the past 4 years, their number has increased 2.5 times. These installations contain pulsed electron accelerators that generate pulsed bremsstrahlung radiation with a maximum energy from 6 to 21 MeV. Currently, there are no devices designed for dosimetry of the pulsed photon radiation with energy of more than 10 MeV in the state register of measuring instruments of the Russian Federation. The most widely used radiation monitoring device for pulsed electron accelerators is the DKS-AT1123 X-ray and gamma radiation dosimeter designed for dosimetry of pulsed bremsstrahlung radiation with an energy of up to 10 MeV. The purpose of this work is to evaluate the possibility of using this device for dosimetry of pulsed bremsstrahlung radiation with a maximum energy of up to 20 MeV. The authors calculated the energy spectra of bremsstrahlung radiation for a point source with a maximum energy of 20 MeV behind flat concrete screens with a thickness of 1 m, 2 m and 3 m by the Monte Carlo method using the GEANT4 calculation program. The energy dependence of the registration efficiency of the DKS-AT1123 dosimeter was extrapolated to the energy range of 10–50 MeV in the kerma-approximation without taking into account the energy transfer by secondary electrons. It was assumed that it corresponds to the energy dependence of the total mass attenuation coefficient for the absorbed energy of gamma quanta in water. Using conversion coefficients for converting the fluence of monoenergetic photons into the effective dose rate at an anterior-posterior radiation incidence on the human body, real dose rates were calculated, and using the energy dependence of the dosimeter readings, the predicted results of measuring the unit dose rate with the DKS-AT1123 dosimeter behind a concrete protection with a thickness of 1, 2 and 3 m were obtained. It is shown that the maximum expected underestimation of the measurement results will not exceed 40% and practically does not depend on the thickness of the concrete shield in the thickness range from 1 to 3 m. To account for this underestimation, it is necessary to use the value of additional measurement error due to the energy dependence of the sensitivity of this device for the photon radiation energy of more than 10 MeV, equal to 70%. This makes it possible to use the measurement results obtained using this dosimeter to adequately characterize the state of radiation safety during operation of pulsed electron accelerators with a maximum energy of up to 20 MeV. It is possible to use a correction factor to the measurement results equal to 1.63 ±0.04 to compensate for this underestimation. The proposed approach can be used to create a methodology for using this dosimeter for radiation monitoring of medical electron accelerators with the energy of up to 20 MeV, if there are correction factors for radiation protection configurations and radiation energies encountered in practice.
In the paper, based on the analysis of scientific information regarding the parameters and characteris-tics of radiation fields for three dental X-ray procedures (intraoral radiographs, panoramic radiographs on orthopantomographs and computed tomography), the required thickness of stationary shields for rooms with different X-ray equipment is calculated. It has been shown that in most cases, in rooms where intraoral and panoramic radiographs are taken, conventional 20 mm thick plasterboard interior room partitions provide the necessary protection to comply with the dose limit for the population in the adjacent room. For the rooms where dental examinations are carried out using computed tomographs additional lead shield up to 1.5 mm thick is required depending on the conditions and the category of protected persons in the adjacent room.
Cytogenetic Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization studies, that allow assessing the frequency of stable chromosome aberrations in circulating T lymphocytes, are commonly used in retrospective dosimetry in cases of uniform whole-body exposure. In the event of 89,90Sr exposure, interpretation of cytogenetic data is challenging, especially if blood sampling occurs long after the start of exposure. The weighted average dose to T-lymphocytes at the time of donor blood sampling in the long-term period after exposure to 89,90Sr does not coincide with the red bone marrow dose. Previously, we developed a model that allows us to estimate the weighted average doses to T-lymphocytes upon 89,90Sr ingress into the body of people belonging to various age groups. In this study, the modeling results were used to estimate the conversion factors from the frequency of translocations to the red bone marrow dose, which is important for assessing radiobiological effects associated with hematological diseases. The objective of our study is to estimate numerically the conversion factors (Brbm) from the dose to lymphocytes to the dose to red bone marrow for various scenarios of 89,90Sr ingestion depending on age, sex, and time after the start of exposure. The following scenarios are considered: single, uniform chronic for six months, uniform chronic for 1-5 years, non-uniform intake for 5 years (simulates the dynamics of intake in the Techa riverside settlements in 1950-1954). As a result, it has been found that the Brbm values significantly depend on the age at the time of 89,90Sr intake. The older the person is at the start of exposure, the more the cytogenetic dose differs (it is significantly lower) from the dose to the red bone marrow. We can say that the cytogenetic dose corresponds to the red bone marrow dose only in newborns and infants. This is due to the age-related dynamics of T-cell populations. Sex does not have a significant effect on Brbm. The effect of the 89,90Sr intake duration on Brbm is the most pronounced for 15-year-old adolescents. For them, the difference in Brbm values for a single and chronic 5-year ingress reaches 13%. Non-uniform intake of 90Sr over several years does not have a significant effect on Brbm and can be modelled by a uniform intake of the same duration.
The study assessed the acceptability of the currently existing approach to calculating shielding in computed tomography rooms and formulated proposals for its improvement, taking into account the parameters of research in domestic medical practice. It is proposed to use the dose-length product as the main measured parameter in the new approach to calculating shielding. Typical tomograph workload values of dose-length product, typical for examinations in the Russian Federation, were assessed. Using thermoluminescent detectors, the experimental assessment of the distribution of absorbed dose in the air in a computed tomography room was carried out. The experimental results showed that the distribution of of X-ray exposure in the central plane is not isotropic. Due to the attenuation of exposure by the gantry design, “shadow” zones are observed, where the absorbed dose reduction in the air reaches 10-13 times compared to its level in the direction of couch movement. Based on the results of measurements of the distribution of absorbed dose in air, the relative scatter coefficients were calculated. The workload was determined for 7 tomographs (1 in St. Petersburg and 6 in Moscow). For each tomograph, the average weekly number of head and body examinations and the values of dose-length product for these areas were assessed, taking into account the number of multiphase examinations. The obtained workload values turned out to be one or two orders of magnitude higher than those currently used in calculating shielding. Based on the results of the study and literature data, the work proposes a new approach to calculating shielding in computed tomography rooms, based on the value of measured dose-length product during the examination and allowing to take into account the specifics of the operation of the device.
The article proposes a new approach to assessing the effective doses of flaw detectorists performing flaw detection using portable radionuclide flaw detectors (gamma flaw detectors). The existing approach to assessing effective doses, based on the use of one individual dosimeter placed on work clothes in the chest area, is inadequate for the actual working conditions of exposure of flaw detectorists. Gamma flaw detectors contain a closed man-made source of ionizing radiation in their head, therefore, even in the non-working position, such flaw detectors pose a radiation hazard. When transporting and preparing gamma flaw detectors for work, the flaw detector operator is in close proximity to the radiation source. The irradiation geometry changing during the technological cycle when working with portable gamma flaw detectors at certain stages creates a sharply uneven irradiation of the flaw detectorist’s body. Therefore, after assessing the stages of the technological cycle, an option was proposed for a more conservative assessment of effective doses – to change the location of the individual dosimeter on the working clothes of the flaw detectorist, moving the individual dosimeter to the abdominal area. An anonymous study was carried out with the participation of 15 flaw detectorists; three individual dosimeters were displayed on their working clothes: two of them were experimental and were placed in the chest and abdomen; the third (a control dosimeter) was exposed for the quarter on the chest as part of constant individual dosimetric monitoring. In controlled anonymous measurements, the average effective dose, estimated from the readings of dosimeters exposed in the chest area, was equal to 0,95 mSv (median – 0,92 mSv, maximum value – 1,27 mSv). These values were compared with values obtained using dosimeters that were exposed to the abdomen, and the differences were significant (the average effective dose was 1,24 mSv (median – 1,22 mSv, maximum value – 1,78 mSv).
The paper presents the results of analysis of the Ivanovo Regional databank of radiation doses to the pub-lic from exposure to natural and technologically enhanced radiation background for 2008–2022. Despite the fact that the average individual annual effective dose of public exposure due to natural sources of radiation in the Ivanovo region calculated for the whole 15-year period (4.63 mSv/year) does not qualify as increased (i.e. does not exceed the level of 5 mSv/year), in some years of the period under review the average dose repeatedly exceeded this level, reaching 7.50 mSv/year. The analysis of the structure of the doses of public exposure due to natural sources of radiation in the Ivanovo region showed that the contribution of the dose from internal exposure to radon, thoron and progenies according to measurement results from 2008–2022 ranged from 65.98 to 81.47%. The paper provides examples of buildings of different types in settlements of the Ivanovo region, in which the indoor radon isotopes equilibrium equivalent concentrations are more than 1.5 times higher than the established action level for existing dwellings and public buildings (200 Bq/m3). Despite the significant amount of measurement data in the Regional databank, it is necessary to obtain additional information on the indoor radon levels in existing wooden and other low-rise dwellings and public buildings in the most radon-prone areas of the region. For this purpose, a radon survey is planned for 2024-2026 in the cities of Ivanovo and Kohma, Privolzhsky, Gavrilovo-Posadsky, Teykovsky and Zavolzhsky districts of the Ivanovo region within the framework of a joint project of Saint-Petersburg Research Institute of Radiation Hygiene after Professor P.V. Ramzaev, the Directorate of the Federal Service for Surveillance on Consumer Rights Protection and Human Wellbeing in the Ivanovo region, and the Center of Hygiene and Epidemiology in the Ivanovo region.
Radiopharmaceutical therapy with 131I has been one of the most common types of radiopharmaceutical therapy for many years. Radiation safety of the public is ensured by limiting the patient contacts until the radiological parameters are reduced to the established criteria. To increase the availability of the radiopharmaceutical therapy with 131I, softer patient release criteria for 131I have been proposed. However, early patient release may increase exposure to the public, e.g. in transport. The aim of the work is to evaluate the radiation exposure from patients with 131I -MIBG and Na131I on the public in transport considering the generation of biological waste. In this work, 131I excretion from the body of patients in transport was evaluated for different scenarios of patient travel to the place of residence. As a result, it was found that mitigation of patient release criteria leads to an increase in the effective dose to the public in transport and an increase in the 131I activity excreted with patient waste. The specific activity in the tanks of biotoilets in transport, generated after the pas -sage of a patient with injected 131I -labeled radiopharmaceuticals, exceeds the limit value of classifying liquid waste as radioactive. To optimize radiation protection of the public, it is advisable to apply a differentiated approach to release patients after therapy with 131I: to group non-resident patients into a separate category retaining for them the established release criterion (without mitigation) to minimize the radiation impact on the public.
The article presents results of the analysis of questionnaire survey data on preferences in the choice of cooking methods of different types of forest mushrooms by residents of the most contaminated south-western districts of the Bryansk region in the remote period after the Chernobyl accident. In the period from 2019 to 2022, the employees of Federal Budgetary Institution of Science «Saint-Petersburg Research Institute of Radiation Hygiene after Professor P.V. Ramzaev» conducted a face-to-face questionnaire survey of the adult population. In addition to general questions about the respondent, the questionnaires included questions about the species composition of the mushroom basket, the volume and proportion of consumption of each type of mushroom by the respondent and his family members (both in the current and last year), as well as methods of culinary processing of the mushrooms consumed. Based on the analysis of individual survey data, a group of 1 311 respondents, whose diet included various types of mushrooms, was selected. Analysis of the survey results showes that respondents prefer to process a large proportion of freshly picked forest mushrooms (59%) for long-term storage (pickling, freezing, drying, salting, etc.); 41% of mushrooms are consumed immediately. The most popular pretreatments of freshly picked mushrooms are washing and boiling (34 and 26%, respectively). When freezing, pickling and pickling up to 97% of respondents carry out pre-treatment (rinsing, soaking and / or boiling) of freshly picked mushrooms. Less popular methods of the mushroom preparation (from 2 to 4%) are pickling, drying and frying of fresh mushrooms with their subsequent preservation. Thus, the majority of respondents actively use various types of culinary processing with the use of preliminary stages of technological processing in the form of rinsing, soaking and (or) boiling. The use of the above methods of pre-cooking of freshly harvested mushrooms leads to a decrease in the 137Cs content in the consumed product.
Radiation safety for the decommissioning of the nuclear legacy facilities
The Arctic zone is a strategically important territory of the Russian Federation from the point of view of socio-economic, scientific, and technological components, as well as in terms of planning the development of a system for ensuring national defense, state, and public security. Intensive exploration and development of Arctic territories, combined with a rapidly changing environment due to global climate change, carries a few risks for the environment. This determines the need to assess potential environmental damage and determine the significance of factors of potential negative impact on unique Arctic ecosystems now and in the future. The article presents current data from a radiation survey of the coastal zone of residential areas close to the site of the sinking of the nuclear submarine ‘K-159’ – Teriberka village and Kildin Island, Murmansk region, as well as the sea area to assess the primary levels of man-made and natural radionuclides before starting work on the potential lifting of the submerged object. This work was carried out as part of the implementation of the State Program of the Russian Federation ‘Health Development’ (approved by Decree of the Government of the Russian Federation dated December 26, 2017, No. 1640). The results of measuring the ambient dose equivalent rate of gamma radiation in open areas and determining the content of man-made and natural radionuclides in samples of environmental media (soil, aquatic vegetation, marine aquatic organisms) and food products of local origin and production (mushrooms, berries, fish, milk). The research results showed that the state of the study area is generally stable in terms of the radiation factor, the content of radionuclides is at the background level. As part of this work, electronic database modules have been developed based on the results of radiation monitoring in Teriberka village and on Kildin Island. Certificate No. 2022621890 was received on registration of a database with the results of the radiation situation of the above-mentioned territories.
Discussions
The paper presents comments, remarks and opinions on the material presented in the publication “Radon regulation crisis in Russia: scale of the problem and proposals for remediation” by Tsapalov A., Miklyaev P., Petrova T., Kuvshinnikov S., published in the Russian peer-reviewed journal “ANRI” (“Radiation measurement equipment and news”), 2024, No. 1.
Radiation measuRements
The paper (in two parts) presents an overview of the new guidelines MR 2.6.1.0333-23 (approved on 01 December 2023) that supersede guidelines MU 2.6.1.2838-11, which were used for organizing radiation surveys of residential, public and industrial buildings and facilities and their sanitary assessment in terms of radiation safety indicators over the past 12 years. Due to a large number of critical comments on the document received during this period, a need for significant revision emerged. The scope of the revised document was expanded and now covers all stages of the life cycle of buildings and facilities: commissioning; operation period; overhaul and reconstruction; demolition. In the first part of the paper, the structure and legal status of the new guidelines are considered, as well as the main innovations in terms of measuring the ambient dose equivalent rate of gamma radiation, searching and identifying local radiation anomalies and sites of radioactive contamination, measuring surface contamination levels, and determining the minimum number of premises to be surveyed. The reasons for the introduction of certain changes are outlined. The issues of evaluation of measurement uncertainty, reporting of measurement results and registration of test reports are covered in detail. In the second part of the paper, numerous innovations will be considered in terms of estimating the indoor average annual equilibrium equivalent concentration of radon isotopes.
Activities of gamma-emitting radionuclides were measured in glassy inclusions (particles) found in soil samples from the “Taiga” peaceful nuclear explosions site (the Perm region, Russia). The measurements were performed using a stationary semiconductor gamma spectrometer. Activity concentrations were determined for the following technogenic radionuclides: 60Co, 94Nb, 137Cs, 152Eu, 154Eu, 155Eu, and 241Am. The activity concentrations of 241Am in the glassy inclusions were one to two orders of magnitude higher compared to the level of minimum significant activity concentration (1 Bq/g for 241Am) established by the Russian Radiation Safety Standards “NRB-99/2009”. Earlier, exceeding this level for the 241Am activity concentration in the native (unfractionated) soil samples from the “Taiga” site was reported by other researchers. In accordance with current Russian legislative and regulatory provisions regarding use of nuclear charges for peaceful purposes, the soil and radioactive glassy inclusions found in the soil correspond to the category of special radioactive waste. Considering the long half-life of 241Am (432 years), radiologically significant contamination by this radionuclide will persist at the “Taiga” site for the foreseeable future.
ISSN 2409-9082 (Online)